Half a croissant, on a plate, with a sign in front of it saying '50c'

h a l f b a k e r y
Faster than a stationary bullet.

idea: add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, best, random

meta: news, help, about, links, report a problem

account: Browse anonymously, or get an account and write.

User:
Pass:

or Create a new account.


                                         

USB flash drive with built in cross-platform antivirus, somehow
  (+4, -2)
(+4, -2)
  [vote for,
against]


I've got a USB flash drive (that is also a SD card) that seems to have picked up a virus. I only use about three IBM PC clones running 'windows' and only very occasionally at that. Somehow my insertion into a computer running 'windows', must've picked up something, which, ages later was detected the next time I encountered another.

Of course, it doesn't matter much to me, as it probably doesn't affect OS X or Gentoo linux.

However, it'd be a nice idea if USB flash drives could be made to accommodate a cross-platform updatable automatically runnable antivirus program that scans everything on the way in or out.

Possible ways of doing it:
• incorporate a small cheap ARM or similar with the drive, so that the execution of the antivirus isn't dependent upon a host computer to run a program (the host computer might run an infrequently encountered OS such as Risc OS or Amiga OS or some such lonely effort). This presents updating problems.
• write it in Java, allow it to execute only within that directory. But that doesn't suggest a means of automatically invoking it upon insertion.
• give up.


Ian Tindale, Oct 19 2007

Linux user at BestBuy http://xkcd.com/272/
I love this guy. [bleh, Oct 19 2007]

[link]






       Wouldn't it make more sense to have this "gatekeeper" software on the computer, to preclude viruses from loaded to or from all USB drives, regardless of their own capabilities?

MaxwellBuchanan, Oct 19 2007
  

       No. I might conceivably use a different computer next time.

Ian Tindale, Oct 19 2007
  

       Then it's the responibility of the computer's owner.   

       It could invoke itself easily upon the supply of power - lots of things do it.   

       There may be some future in USB mounted software, antivirus or not.

wagster, Oct 19 2007
  

       (-) Thanks, but I'd rather not have this. Adding automatically executable hoo-hah to storage media is what got us into this mess to begin with.

jutta, Oct 19 2007
  

       Well, it doesn't really bother me either because it's hardly likely to affect my own computer. I was just feeling a bit of misplaced empathy with people at various places I work at that have to run 'windows'.   

       I put the card into my Nikon D50 to reformat it in the end.

Ian Tindale, Oct 19 2007
  

       I haven't had a virus in years. I was beginning to think they were just bogeymen invented by McAfee et. al. to sell us software.

wagster, Oct 19 2007
  

       You now have a virus [wagster] !!!!! Look very closely at the symbol enclosed by the backets [ ] It's called the White Space Envelope. Every piece of text on this whole page is now surrounded by it, and you can never get rid of it !

xenzag, Oct 19 2007
  

       I had WSE on my computer, but got rid of it by running a little utility called ShutDown.

normzone, Oct 19 2007
  

       I have an Ativa brand flash drive with U3 software on it. It's set up to emulate a CD drive, and is supposed to carry programs from computer to computer for me. One of the free programs supplied on it was anti-virus software (which I already had on my computer).   

       I've never taken that flash drive to another computer, and almost formatted all that shite off it. But I have a dozen other flash drives (it's a compulsion) so I left it as it was.   

       It's an anti-virus on a flash drive, technically, I suppose. But it's a pain to use.

baconbrain, Oct 19 2007
  

       I had the U3 crap on my drives also but I formatted it off. I cant stand that shit. Popping up every time I plug the thing in. <grunt> <stomp>   

       not only that, but the U3 crap does not work on Mac. Bastards.

bleh, Oct 19 2007
  

       Not a virus but it might as well be:   

       Anyone else have the problem of their Mac gradually filling up their flash drive by not actually deleting old information from it but just moving it to a hidden '.trashes' folder?   

       It's a real pain when using a digital camera's memory card with a Mac.   

       Every now and then I have to either tediously invoke showing hidden files on my Mac to delete the unwanted files or pop the flash drive into a PC.   

       Or is it Apple's way of punishing me for not porting photos using i(DontWantToStoreYour)Photo?

boysparks, Oct 19 2007
  

       //Anyone else have the problem of their Mac gradually filling up their flash drive by not actually deleting old information from it but just moving it to a hidden '.trashes' folder? //   

       You have to empty the trash while the drive is plugged in. I have noticed this too. I get into the habit of delete- empty trash to keep this stuff from piling up. If you empty the trash with the drive plugged in it should go away. Also works with cameras

bleh, Oct 20 2007
  

       Thanks, that helps a lot. It never occurred to me that the Mac's Trash Can would link to separate drives, but it makes sense now.

boysparks, Oct 20 2007
  

       Seems easier to simply run your own antivirus software to scan your usb drive. More effective, too, because it will remind you to scan your hard disk as well.

shapu, Oct 20 2007
  

       The thing is, I really don't care about other people getting viruses, and other operating systems viruses won't affect my computer, so really I should just carry on the way I am - freely infecting 'windows' computers wherever I go because one of them gave me a virus, and I was unaware of it in my normal use of my own iBook.

Ian Tindale, Oct 20 2007
  

       [Ian Tindale] = Patient Zero

elhigh, Oct 23 2007
  

       [Ian Tindale] = Zero Patience...

lostdog, Oct 23 2007
  

       antivirus is snake oil. also, use a secure operating system like openbsd.

erlehmann, Jan 09 2008
  
      
[annotate]
  


 
back: main index
 business 
 computer 
 culture 
 fashion 
 food 
 halfbakery 
 home 
 other 
 product 
 public 
 science 
 sport 
 vehicle