Half a croissant, on a plate, with a sign in front of it saying '50c'

h a l f b a k e r y
Warm and Fussy

idea: add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, best, random

meta: news, help, about, links, report a problem

account: Browse anonymously, or get an account and write.

User:
Pass:

or Create a new account.


                 

Clustervotes
Harness local experts for national voting.
 
(+2, -2)
  [vote for,
against]


</rant> </bait> [This is neither intended a rant nor a bait, but a genuine idea.]

When you are buying a car, seems there's always someone in your group of friends who is known as the most mechanically-minded, car-loving freak.

When going overseas, you can quickly harness the six-degrees-of-separation tactic to find advice/tips for the cities you're visiting.

Could the self-organising system of local networks produce a better voting system? Let's see:

I've always insisted we should vote for policies more than we vote for people. Otherwise we end up with rock stars and actors as leaders.

So: Votes are categorised into general disciplines (economy, health, education, manufacturing, justice, natural resources, etc).

Your votes are then (SOMEHOW????) weighted by a system of scoring amongst your peers.

'Oh, Jim spent that 3 weeks in hospital last year -- he'll know better than me if those nurses are over/underworked.'

'Tim says he cares about trees, but he never says what should be done about it. I'll weight-up Susan, since she was the one who asked the local council to examine her ideas on funding some green areas among the developments.'

?


not_only_but_also, Oct 18 2004

Halfbakery: real-time forest voting http://www.halfbake...e_20forest_20voting
My (surprisingly similar) attempt at attacking this problem: If you think someone near you is competent in an area, give them your vote. [jutta, Oct 18 2004]

[link]






       Are rock stars and actors inherently bad choices for leaders?

bristolz, Oct 18 2004
  

       They make great leaders, but they tend to rely on auto-cues too much. :)

not_only_but_also, Oct 18 2004
  

       Would this require voters to pay attention to the real issues, rather than voting the way they do (because they support baseball team X, football team Y and political party Z) just like the rest of their family?

UnaBubba, Oct 18 2004
  

       So every appointed position that oversees these issues would become a vote?   

       Destined to become abused by the parties, unfortunately.

RayfordSteele, Oct 23 2004
  

       I agree, way too open to abuse. Sorry, gonna have to bone this despite an admirable concept. Human nature will get you every time.

harderthanjesus, Oct 23 2004
  

       I agree with [RS] and [htj] on this one.   

       By the way, did you hear about the guy who was selling his vote for the upcoming Presidential election on e-bay for $25? The sucker's likely to be thrown in jail for at least a year for the misdemeanor.

Machiavelli, Oct 23 2004
  
      
[annotate]
  


 
back: main index
 business 
 computer 
 culture 
 fashion 
 food 
 halfbakery 
 home 
 other 
 product 
 public 
 science 
 sport 
 vehicle