h a l f b a k e r y
"It would work, if you can find alternatives to each of the steps involved in this process."
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
or get an account
Social media is getting increasingly bad reputation. It is
associated with short attention spans, shallow content and
false information. I believe this is because we get what
we measure. Measure money: Get greed. Measure likes:
Get cat videos. Measure retweets: Get Donald Trump.
delta-V: get moon landing. Measure weight: get
What if we measured thoughtfulness of content? This new
media platform would work pretty much like facebook,
twitter, reddit etc. But instead of giving thumbs up, likes
followers and retweets, content would be ranked by
Thoughtfulness would be rated by participants on the
platform. Giving a + would signify the content I read made
me think new thoughts. Giving a - would signify the
To avoid the scourge of inevitable "thought bots" and
"thought farms" designed to artificially boost an content's
ranking, we could also design it in such a way that the
feedback itself had to be thoughtful. Instead of just
mashing the thumbs up/down button all day, what if the
feedback had to be thoughtful comment in itself? - sort of
like a peer review. Instead of social capital, participants
would have to start accumulating thoughtfulness capital
instead. Participants would also create a thoughtfulness
graph, based on their impact and relation to each other.
Thoughtfulness graph would capture inspiration by others
rather than friendship.
Why thoughtfulness? As a human civilization we can easily
handle well thought out opposing ideas. In fact we benefit
from such situations. But our civilization will crumble if
we only consider the first shallow thought that pops into
our minds. Since AI and bots are not yet capable of being
very thoughtful, it also serves as an effective CAPTCHA
mechanism without the associated annoyance and spying
||// Since AI and bots are not yet capable of being very thoughtful, //
||<Paddington Special Hard Stare/>
||You"re really keen on putting your name down for a slapping, ain't ya ?
||All right then - come on chummy if you think you're hard enough, we will kick your head in ...
||//Thoughtfulness would be rated by participants on the platform. Giving a + would signify the content I read made me think new thoughts. Giving a - would signify the opposite.//
||This overlaps with my old Mind Horizon Profile idea which would create ratings of the knowledge contained in the viewers head so it could compare against a similar multi-dimensional rating for the content. In theory this could predict the knowledge to be had for a particular viewer from e.g. any YouTube video, without watching it.
||I'm all for better categorisation of content rather than censorship. [+]
||I like this, and might bake it. It would fit in well with a
content aggregator and discussion site I've been thinking
||// Giving a + would signify the content I read made me
think new thoughts. Giving a - would signify the opposite.
||/r/changemyview on Reddit is kinda like that.