Half a croissant, on a plate, with a sign in front of it saying '50c'
h a l f b a k e r y
Sugar and spice and unfettered insensibility.

idea: add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random

meta: news, help, about, links, report a problem

account: browse anonymously, or get an account and write.

user:
pass:
register,


                                               

Great Moments in War Avoidance Reenactment Societies

Practice and celebrate imitation of the Real heroes
  (+8, -2)
(+8, -2)
  [vote for,
against]

Up and down the former thirteen colonies, you can find amateur reenactment societies devoted to the demonstration of the American Revolutionary timeperiod, and indeed, for just about every conflict, war, skirmish, and battle America's been involved in, there's a fan club that plays the parts of friend and foe on the battlefield.

It makes for an interesting afternoon's outing for families, I suppose.

But is history nothing more than the accumulation of conflicts and bloodshed? (Okay, so maybe it's close to that). What we need are reenactment societies that demonstrate the historical peacable resolutions of conflicts. The near-wars avoided by gutsy decisions, cool-headed soldiers, accidental or on-purpose. Wear the costumes, talk in the language of the day, and expose *them* for all their glory, subconsciously teaching conflict resolution to the masses.

RayfordSteele, Apr 19 2004

Somewhat Related Idea http://www.halfbake...ague_20Of_20Nations
[theircompetitor, Oct 04 2004, last modified Oct 05 2004]

[link]






       Would go well with my pet project of rewriting important tragedies so that people just calm down, misunderstandings are cleared up, and nobody gets hurt.
jutta, Apr 19 2004
  

       "Oh, so it's war, is it?!"
"No, I said, 'It's warM.'"
"Oh. My mistake..."
Detly, Apr 19 2004
  

       I'll bet those are page turners, [jutta].
bristolz, Apr 19 2004
  

       Problem is, the peacefully resolved near-conflicts seldom make the history pages. Maybe they should. Any examples [RayfordSteele]?
booleanfool, Apr 20 2004
  

       Cuban missile crisis.
FarmerJohn, Apr 20 2004
  

       How about reenacting the Northern Ireland peace talks, but using real politicians--and instead of the subject being Northern Ireland, it could be, say, the Basque Country...?   

       [RayfordSteele], an olive branch and a bun.
Arby, Apr 20 2004
  

       jutta could rewrite shakespeare - excellent idea!
po, Apr 20 2004
  

       The reenactment of peace is the stuff of a stage play. the battle reenactments are playing war in real time, A classic entertainment value. I wouldn't trade em.
dentworth, Apr 20 2004
  

       I agree with dentworth's first sentence. Peace can make for drama just as compelling as war but is distinguished by being about words as much as action, so a re-enactment would be best suited to a stage.

As FarmerJohn pointed out, the Cuban Missile Crisis is one of the first examples that springs to mind and I've seen the (real) film of the Yugoslav governing council meeting where, despite the intimidatory atmosphere, the non-Serb members of the council refused to allow the imposition of a state of emergency. Fascinating stuff.

In response to jutta:

MACBETH: We will proceed no further in this business: He hath honour'd me of late; and I have bought Golden opinions from all sorts of people, Which would be worn now in their newest gloss, Not cast aside so soon

LADY MACBETH: Hmm! I see your point wise husband. Let us away from this draughty courtyard and hi us back to our warm chamber. Mayhap we can rescue aught of value from this wasted night, eh big boy?
DrBob, Apr 20 2004
  

       //LADY MACBETH: Hmm! I see your point wise husband. Let us away from this draughty courtyard and hi us back to our warm chamber. Mayhap we can rescue aught of value from this wasted night, eh big boy?//   

       marvellous DB. <applause>
po, Apr 20 2004
  

       India and Pakistan come to mind. And a whole travelogue with Jimmy Carter.   

       I'd bet there are many that government types can't talk about that would read like Clancy novels.
RayfordSteele, Apr 20 2004
  

       There are probably others that government types won't talk about that would appear like "I Love Lucy" episodes.
booleanfool, Apr 20 2004
  

       Complete with Cuban accents.
booleanfool, Apr 20 2004
  

       In retrospect, it's easy to see that every historic tragedy owes its roothold to a crisis of less than 15 minutes duration; easily enough time to avert the overreaction sequence that would eventually consume lives, fortunes, or armies.
dpsyplc, Apr 20 2004
  

       I really like this. I don't think that such important peaceable moments in history are emphasised enough.   

       <slight aside>
"The referee consults the linesman - no goal!..
...
Some people are on the pitch... they think it's all over...
but the referee has sent off Geoff Hurst. Play continues..."
  

       I know that it isn't war - and is a fictional re-write - but after reading the annos about [jutta]s pet it just jumped into my head. (And props to DrBob)   

       (later: thanks [po] - I honestly knew the spelling but brain disengaged this morning
[britboy]: good choice - I recommend reading Beevor's 'Berlin' as soon as you recover from Stalingrad)
Jinbish, Apr 21 2004
  

       Good idea .. But the sad truth is, peace isn't as exciting as war.   

       I'm reading about Stalingrad at the moment. I think all politicians should be forced to read this book -- it truly puts war into its proper light.
britboy, Apr 21 2004
  

       Jin, sp: Hurst.
po, Apr 21 2004
  

       britboy -- while you're at it, read some more about Stalin, East Germany, Chechoslovakia and Hungary. It'll trully put not going to war in the proper context as well.
theircompetitor, Apr 21 2004
  

       One could also choose to portray what happened in those countries around 1989, or the fall of apartheid in South Africa, or mainland China and Taiwan’s decades-long delicate dance.
FarmerJohn, Apr 21 2004
  

       Reenact Kissinger getting the peace prize for the Vietnam peaceful resolution. And then reenact the Tamils.
pashute, Dec 11 2012
  

       // The violence itself is entertaining. //   

       [marked-for-tagline]
8th of 7, Dec 11 2012
  

       The problem is how do you tell? George Washington probably prevented several wars by peacefully retiring at the end of his term as president, but it's debatable.
MechE, Dec 11 2012
  
      
[annotate]
  


 

back: main index

business  computer  culture  fashion  food  halfbakery  home  other  product  public  science  sport  vehicle