Half a croissant, on a plate, with a sign in front of it saying '50c'
h a l f b a k e r y
Flaky rehab

idea: add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random

meta: news, help, about, links, report a problem

account: browse anonymously, or get an account and write.

user:
pass:
register,


                     

Public Opinion Solves Arguments

Personal arguments .. let the public decide.
  (+1, -3)
(+1, -3)
  [vote for,
against]

I had no idea what category to put this one in.

Arguments. Everyday, everywhere. How often are you arguing your point against more than one opponent, knowing 100% for certain you are correct, but for whatever reason they side with eachother and do their best to humiliate you? Yeah. Well, how's this. Arguments can be displayed publicly - the net is obviously a first choice.

The opposing sides give their account of the argument, perhaps by text or email or whatever, and the public are left to decide who is in the right. Arguments can be scrolled through in much the same way as you scroll through categories here on halfbakery, and the public can vote for whom they think is correct. At the end of the alloted time, the argument is settled publicly.

The obvious downside is if the argument itself is a complicated one, and of course, can people be bothered to spend their time filling out an 'account' of their argument?

Yes, the idea has a couple of holes .. but if your 'opposer' is a particularly argumentative or arrogant sort and you want to stick it to them, do it publicly. Just make sure you're right!

Note: I've read the Public Resolution idea, and this doesn't involve the legal system, it's more an idea to passively air your view publicly .. and of course, it doesn't warrant people beating the hell out of eachother!

Note II: Spelling corrected, courtesy of Jinbish. Thx ;)

kuupuuluu, Apr 24 2006

[link]






       Public opinion might solve spelling...   

       Can you give an example of an argument that this forum would be used for? And what method do you propose for publicising these 'arguments'?
Jinbish, Apr 24 2006
  

       I would have thought a hotornot style rating of opinions would work quite well.   

       Probably wouldnt take too long to set up either
miasere, Apr 24 2006
  

       The public is a bunch of idiots.
ato_de, Apr 25 2006
  

       Grab your tourches and pitchforks!   

       //Public Opinion Solves Arguments//
Its been my experience that 'opinion's rarely solve anything.
Letsbuildafort, Apr 25 2006
  

       For more specific arguments, you could gather say 12 members of the public, and have them listen to all the facts and arguments of a particular argument, and then decide, one way or another...
zen_tom, Apr 25 2006
  

       Its better to be tried by 12 than carried by 6.
Letsbuildafort, Apr 25 2006
  

       [boysparks] Nah it doesn't happen to me very often at all actually. It was an impulse-bake to be honest. Some people never see anything from anyone elses POV, and when they know they're losing an argument they attempt to make others look foolish. I saw it the other day and it just irritated me ..
kuupuuluu, Apr 25 2006
  

       //Note II: Spelling corrected, courtesy of Jinbish// Only a few remaining.
coprocephalous, Apr 25 2006
  

       I'm not sure what is wrong with people beating the hell out of each other, but I am sure that the "public" would rather watch that than think about which one of your loser friends is right about President Bush's underware choices.
ato_de, Apr 25 2006
  
      
[annotate]
  


 

back: main index

business  computer  culture  fashion  food  halfbakery  home  other  product  public  science  sport  vehicle