h a l f b a k e r y
Poof of concept
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
or get an account
[This is neither intended a rant nor a bait, but a genuine idea.]
When you are buying a car, seems there's always someone in your group of friends who is known as the most mechanically-minded, car-loving freak.
When going overseas, you can quickly harness the six-degrees-of-separation
tactic to find advice/tips for the cities you're visiting.
Could the self-organising system of local networks produce a better voting system? Let's see:
I've always insisted we should vote for policies more than we vote for people. Otherwise we end up with rock stars and actors as leaders.
So: Votes are categorised into general disciplines (economy, health, education, manufacturing, justice, natural resources, etc).
Your votes are then (SOMEHOW????) weighted by a system of scoring amongst your peers.
'Oh, Jim spent that 3 weeks in hospital last year -- he'll know better than me if those nurses are over/underworked.'
'Tim says he cares about trees, but he never says what should be done about it. I'll weight-up Susan, since she was the one who asked the local council to examine her ideas on funding some green areas among the developments.'
Halfbakery: real-time forest voting
My (surprisingly similar) attempt at attacking this problem: If you think someone near you is competent in an area, give them your vote. [jutta, Oct 19 2004]
Please log in.
If you're not logged in,
you can see what this page
looks like, but you will
not be able to add anything.
Description (displayed with the short name and URL.)
||Are rock stars and actors inherently bad choices for leaders?
||They make great leaders, but they tend to rely on auto-cues too much. :)
||So every appointed position that oversees these issues would become a vote?
||Destined to become abused by the parties, unfortunately.
||I agree, way too open to abuse. Sorry, gonna have to bone this despite an admirable concept. Human nature will get you every time.
||I agree with [RS] and [htj] on this one.
||By the way, did you hear about the guy who was selling his vote for the upcoming Presidential election on e-bay for $25? The sucker's likely to be thrown in jail for at least a year for the misdemeanor.