h a l f b a k e r yOn the one hand, true. On the other hand, bollocks.
add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random
news, help, about, links, report a problem
browse anonymously,
or get an account
and write.
register,
|
|
|
After thinking up this Idea, wishing I could afford to build it, and
finally deciding to post it here, I looked around to see what there
might already be, and only saw one thing (first link). This is
definitely different in various ways.
From the subtitle one might first think of a steam-whistle
calliope, (second link) but steam-whistles don't sound like human
whistles. I want this instrument to make musical whistles that
are so similar to human whistles that it is difficult to tell the
difference. For examples of good musical human whistling, try
the third link.
If one had such an instrument, it wouldn't matter how badly you
whistle in the normal way, you could become just as musical by
playing the instrument!
So, what are the mechanics of human whistling, such that it might
be duplicated by an instrument? The Wikipedia article (fourth
link) notes that the shape of the mouth and the position of the
tongue can affect the tone of the whistle, while the thing that
actually vibrates, to make the sound in the first place, is nothing
more than the air itself, moving through the puckered lips.
If air flows slowly, it can also flow smoothly and silently. Faster-
flowing air can become turbulent and noisy. The interior shape of
the empty part of the human mouth, through which the air flows,
is so adjustable (via jaw, tongue, and cheeks) that the quality of
the noise can vary considerably, mostly from "breathy" to musical.
In terms of existing devices, there is a non-steam calliope that
employs flowing air; at the fifth linked page you can hear the
noise of the fan as well as the sound from the pipes. It happens
that the pipe-sounds are fairly close to musical human whistling,
but metallic. This tells us that to make an accurate-sounding
whistling machine, we will need softer materials for the
pipes...and it would be nice if the fan was a quieter type, too.
I'm sure the steampunk crowd would not want modern plastics
used (which seem to be available in any reasonable degree of
hardness or softness, but appropriate alternatives might still be
findable (soft woods, hard waxes, et cetera). Experimentation is
in order!
There is a notable thing about the expert whistling in the third
link, and that is all the musical tones are fairly high-pitched. It
seems that for the human mouth, the lower the pitch, the less
musical is the whistle. This might be something that can be
corrected when building a whistling machine; we would like to
have as full a range of musical notes as most other instruments.
Experimentation is still in order!
Finally, we definitely want this instrument to be able to produce
simultaneous whistles of different tones, allowing either/or
musical chords and the sound of a whole chorus of whistlers.
Another whistling-device Idea
Whistling_20Mouthpiece As mentioned in the main text. [Vernon, Aug 13 2015]
Steam Calliope
https://www.youtube...watch?v=Z1l6dKW62_w As mentioned in the main text. [Vernon, Aug 13 2015]
Some Expert Whistlers
https://www.youtube...watch?v=FK1DCWrW02s As mentioned in the main text. [Vernon, Aug 13 2015]
Wikipedia article
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistling As mentioned in the main text. [Vernon, Aug 13 2015]
Air Calliope
https://www.youtube...watch?v=Olnm66Uxy8U As mentioned in the main text. [Vernon, Aug 13 2015]
Pretty close...
http://realitone.com/realiwhistle/ [2 fries shy of a happy meal, Aug 13 2015]
Please log in.
If you're not logged in,
you can see what this page
looks like, but you will
not be able to add anything.
Destination URL.
E.g., https://www.coffee.com/
Description (displayed with the short name and URL.)
|
|
How would you control this, by a piano keyboard? Much of what identifies a whistling sound is not the harmonic content but the control of pitch (or lack thereof). |
|
|
Some sort of keyboard is probably simplest. |
|
|
[2 fries], I'm not surprised by the link. Electronics appears
to be able to synthesize any possible sound. I needed
something less obvious for posting here, so, an actual
physical single-purpose (but still widely capable) instrument
seemed reasonable. |
|
|
[bigsleep], just for you, since it seems you couldn't deduce a possible tone-creating device from all the data in the main text, imagine an air calliope in which all the metal tone-creating tubes are replaced with blocks of an appropriate plastic, and inside each block is a specially-shaped cavity. Each cavity-shape would be different, and shaped like the interior of the mouth, when a person is whistling a particular tone. Each block would therefore have the equivalent of a "throat" which supplies to the cavity, and "lips" through which air exits the cavity. |
|
|
We might be able to create a wide range of musical whistles from cavities that are identical in shape, but different in size. |
|
|
Ah, [Vernon]. Another winner - a full paragraph's
worth of creativity compressed into a mere 472
words. |
|
| |