Half a croissant, on a plate, with a sign in front of it saying '50c'
h a l f b a k e r y
"Bun is such a sad word, is it not?" -- Watt, "Waiting for Godot"

idea: add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random

meta: news, help, about, links, report a problem

account: browse anonymously, or get an account and write.

user:
pass:
register,


                                                           

Simulated Capital Punishment

"Closure" without murder
  (+5, -7)
(+5, -7)
  [vote for,
against]

One of the few justifications for capital punishment is that it gives the victims (or relatives thereof) "closure." Now rmutt is not going to debate how that justifies state-sponsored murder, but if "closure" is so important, it can be obtained by simulated executions. Instead of administering a lethal injection, just use the sedative part. Witnesses think that the convict is executed when in fact s/he is just deeply sedated. Curtains close on the execution chamber, witnesses can go home with "closure." In time, convict wakes up to first day of life sentence.
rmutt, Oct 26 2001

I've linked this before, but... http://www.prologue...nArghans/Rant1.html
Last paragraph. [angel, Oct 26 2001]

Cyberextruder http://www.cyberext...emplate.asp?page=50
Create your own virtual enemies. [Guncrazy, Oct 26 2001, last modified Oct 04 2004]

The difference between execution... http://www.m-w.com/...ictionary?execution
Entry number 2. [StarChaser, Oct 26 2001, last modified Oct 04 2004]

...and murder. http://www.m-w.com/...n/dictionary?murder
Entry 1. They are not the same thing. 'State sponsored murder' is meaningless. [StarChaser, Oct 26 2001, last modified Oct 04 2004]

Killing Hope http://www.amazon.c...dos/ASIN/1567510523
So this is meaningless too? [rmutt, Jan 08 2002, last modified Oct 04 2004]

I've linked this before, but... http://prologue.nom...my.co.uk/Rant1.html
Last paragraph. [angel, Oct 04 2004]

[link]






       I, who am without guilt, shall cast the first fishbone. First of all, if it were public knowledge that executions are shams, how would that bring "closure" to the families of the victims?   

       On the other hand, if this were a secret scheme (although, how could it be, for long?), I am uncomfortable with the idea of people being imprisoned in secret by a supposedly "open" society. The power to hold a large pool of human beings, in captivity, unknown to the outside world, simply screams for abuse.
Guncrazy, Oct 26 2001
  

       "...simply screams for abuse." Right. And the power to execute a large number of human beings, in captivity, doesn't?
rmutt, Oct 26 2001
  

       I had the idea that after the fake execution, the person would be brain-washed and realeased to work as a gov't agent, as in "La Femme Nikita".
mighty_cheese, Oct 26 2001
  

       I'll keep an eye on this post. This is kindling for Trolls. We’ve got
- capital punishment
- government conspiracy
- Islamic fundamentalism
- the worth of American life
- Viking adventurers
sdm, Oct 26 2001
  

       [sdm]: I thought Viking adventurers could beat up trolls any day of the week, with their big axes and all.   

       I also refer you to the pledge on my profile page.
pottedstu, Oct 26 2001
  

       Big N-O to this one, rmutt. The chances of keeping it secret are absolutely zero. The trick with conspiracies is to keep the number of people involved to a minimum but just just look at all the people you'd need to keep silent for this to work, the executioners, the prisoners, the prison guards and officials, the politicians.
DrBob, Oct 26 2001
  

       I kind of like this one, the keeping it secret part might be hard but this is the halfakery... the problem is it is hard to apeal if you don't oficialy exist... but wait... you can't apeal from a death sentance... and this way if you are proved inocent after your "death" then you could be released somewhere else with a new identity...
RobertKidney, Oct 26 2001
  

       pottedstu, trolls and Vikings both come from Norway. They may be related.   

       My sister got bitten by a moose once. ('course, that was in Sweden, though)
beauxeault, Oct 26 2001
  

       It seemed to me at first view that this was going to be another computer game. Well....why not? The secrecy thing seems impractical, and that of course is a fatal quality here on the hb. Instead, permit the aggrieved to simulate capital punishment as often, as messily, and with as lavish sound effects as they might desire. Probably if you scratch closure, you'll find it's a veneer over revenge, and with adequate fidelity SimCP could provide an awful lot of closure.
hagfish, Oct 26 2001
  

       For the purposes of this little scorecard I'm keeping, that would be 3,000 WTC, some 150 Pentagon, 200+ in four destroyed airliners ... as compared to how many in Afghanistan? Seven? 20? 200? <scribbling in notebook> Bear with me ...   

       Now, presuming this were an Islamic fundamentalist nation, would I drop the nuclear device on Kabul at 2pm today or dusk on Sunday?   

       This would be the problem with being a Muslim fanatic ... I couldn't handle the math.
1percent, Oct 26 2001
  

       If you want to simulate capital punishment with a computer game, you can do it with UnrealTournament, Quake 3, or The Sims. See the link, upload your nemesis' face, and you'll have a digital doppelgänger whom you can frag or torture to your bitter heart's content.
Guncrazy, Oct 26 2001
  

       1percent, I don't wish to fan the flames but, if it wasn't for muslim fanatics (i.e. the medieval Arabs), Europe (and by extension, the USA) wouldn't have a clue what maths is.
DrBob, Oct 26 2001
  

       It is posible to do some maths with roman numerals... It just wouldn't exactly be fun...
RobertKidney, Oct 27 2001
  

       And what did the Hundus ever give us? Nothing!
sdm, Oct 27 2001
  

       This idea would be, as others have said, impractical - you could never keep that big a secret in the US as it is today. Almost w*bn*, perhaps? Unfortunately, I suspect that even if you can get round that, you're just going to end up in a whole 'nother argument about the rightness / wrongness of catering to a victim's desire for "closure" or "revenge"... and I ain't getting into that one.
Guy Fox, Oct 27 2001
  

       I'm pro-death penalty.   

       That said, another substantial problem with this idea is that it's very hard to track down an escaped convict who doesn't officially exist.
Deity, Oct 27 2001
  

       PS: ha! of all the typos to make. You'll notice the I is right next to the O. It was meant to be "Hindus". And they gave us 'zero'. That was a joke. Thanks. <mumble>stupid hands</mumble>
sdm, Oct 28 2001
  

       Yeah, Mitsubishi, but arguably inspired by Howard Hughes H-1 racer.
bristolz, Nov 16 2001
  

       sdm: The Karma Sutra
dare99, Nov 17 2001
  

       Well, not to offend you rmutt, but I really can't take people seriously who speak of themselves in third person narrative. That aside, after reading and rereading your proposal, I must say that I don't think it's stupid or anything, just not practial. I agree, a sedative would be more humane, but as a CP supporter, I feel the need to say 'fry 'em all!' or something equally barbaric. Closure is not found in lies. If you really want to give families/victims closure, see if they'd like to take part in the execution. I personally wouldn't, but I could understand if someone would. That sad individual might gain a better understanding of themself, or maybe they'd just feel like the job had been done adequately. They always say, 'If you want something done right, you've got to do it yourself', right?
spikedshinizzle, Nov 30 2002
  

       I think this idea has potential (+). Keeping the number of people involved to a minimum is easy: make a limited amount of employees multi-task every job. Come to think of it, a few prisoners could be brainwashed to do the easier jobs, like the false executions, or bribing politicians. They could even be used to silence threats to the project. However, what if this has already been baked? Not that it has. Just that, if it has been, the general world knows nothing of it.
Shadow Phoenix, Oct 03 2007
  

       Wow- Capital Punishment has the most fishbones ever...do we need Lower Case Punishment?
xandram, Dec 20 2010
  

       Actually, reading Shadow Phoenix's anno reminds me of the film 'Nikita', where the protaganist murders a policeman and is then subjected to a fake execution and public funeral and then forcibly recruited into the French secret service.
DrBob, Dec 20 2010
  
      
[annotate]
  


 

back: main index

business  computer  culture  fashion  food  halfbakery  home  other  product  public  science  sport  vehicle