Half a croissant, on a plate, with a sign in front of it saying '50c'
h a l f b a k e r y
Getting blown into traffic is never fun.

idea: add, search, annotate, link, view, overview, recent, by name, random

meta: news, help, about, links, report a problem

account: browse anonymously, or get an account and write.

user:
pass:
register,


                     

Socially Acceptable Door Holding Line

Lets, literally, delineate the good people from the not so good.
  (+5)
(+5)
  [vote for,
against]

Holding a door open for someone is a nice thing to do. However, for the British, this apparently simple act is a nightmarish minefield of social awkwardness. In an attempt to appear nice, many will try to go above and beyond by holding a door open for anyone travelling toward a door within line of sight, theoretically several miles. Traditionally, British planners prevented this by ensuring no road, and therefore building, is straight for more than 150ft. This restricts corridor length and therefore imposes a maximum door-holding-open range.

Britain does have long corridors. One is in an old Insane Asylum <link>, and another within an example of brutalist architecture at Leeds University <link>. Subjecting the mentally unstable to long corridors and the inevitable door awkwardness is of course cruel, but this is just one of myriad arguments against the general concept of Leeds University. Other British establishments such as Blenheim palace and RAF Brize Norton, have long corridors, but are generally only accessible to those with extensive training in social and military order and the RAF.

The USA, in a fit of new-country puppy-like enthusiasm, has blundered into the long, straight road concept that precipitated the rise of Rome's decline and defines the metropolitan legacy of certain French and Austrian megalomaniacs. The columns, obelisks, statues and flags are all related symptoms. The road system breeds oversize straight buildings with long corridors. As such, you find yourself holding a door for someone only to find that walking is not among their finer qualities and you're there for 20 mins. Worse, someone holds a door for you, and you feel obligated to walk-jog a short distance. More malicious types might be tempted to hold a door for one of the lazier admin staff when there is significant distance to cover, perhaps enjoying a coffee while they shuffle-shamble their way along, or holding open the wrong door for one of the wide eyed undergrads out of understandable curiosity.

Anyway, to the point, the US door system is like the Wild West at the moment. No one knows what they're doing, leading to low level generalized anxiety and opportunities for the sort of social hooliganism detailed above. Let's solve it. The obvious solution is to demolish large buildings, carefully remodel the road system and introduce some kind of rudimentary social order. However, this could take weeks and in a nod to common sense, a pragmatic intermediate solution is required. I suggest a line. A visible and tasteful one, on the floor and perhaps a raised section on the skirting board to alert the blind*. This line should serve as a visual reference for whether or not you hold open the door. If the person is past the line, you hold it like a civilized person, if not, carry on sir your work is done. From the other person's perspective, if you're within the line you don't need to rush, the distance has been calibrated. Conversely, if the line is ahead of you, it provides an opportunity to slow down, perhaps because you intend to use a side door, or stop for a bit of a gormless stare**

Obviously this is a stopgap, but should alleviate 20-77% of America's stress.

*guide dog retraining should be relatively simple, they're certainly aware of such a glaring problem. **an undergraduate favorite.

bs0u0155, Jul 27 2016

Long Corridor https://en.wikipedi...iki/Friern_Hospital
[bs0u0155, Jul 27 2016]

Needlessly Punitive Social Experiment of Questionable Value. http://performancef...projects/red-route/
[bs0u0155, Jul 27 2016]

Real_20Corridor_20across_20the_20States [calum, Jul 27 2016]

[link]






       Pure genius [+]
8th of 7, Jul 27 2016
  

       In Russia, door holds you.
MaxwellBuchanan, Jul 27 2016
  

       A couple of things:
  

       obligated? What happened to obliged? nobless obligatum de pompt de pompt moc-moc-a-moc indeed; and
  

       the problem of course is that the line solves the problem and creates another. The problem it solves is mild and, given the epic distances between held-open-door and the starting point of the potential threshold crosser, is not that much of a problem, no, for it allows for transatlantic romances, platonic or otherwise, to blossom, seep through the parties and then go stale and sour, and wither and die just as the door is arrived at, all this roiling depth of feeling effected through the use of gesture, looks, glances and, most British of all, charmingly obvious attempts at repression of emotion, yes this chasm of time spent with heel pressed against the shiny footplate on the heavy institutional fire door is a world in which wonders happen, the meet cute in the romcom Tarkovsky never made. This is the problem solved.   

       The problem it creates is altogether more pressing. By giving a solution to the masses, we can be sure that a sick subset of the masses will fail to pay atfuckingtention and instead will hold doors while you are miles away, trying in their cheerful, charmless way to hit you with some of that great American niceness but instead inconveniencing the fuck out of you, making you scuttle like some recently admonished scullerymaid fresh in from the Black Country and unlikely to last long in service. By creating an solution to the problem we create an altogether more irritating crime of transgressing the solution.
calum, Jul 27 2016
  

       //obligated? What happened to obliged? //   

       "Obliged" was OK in the 60's when people had smaller houses and lower disposable incomes. "Obligated" was introduced in the 80's for the aspirational classes. Now, of course, people are once again dissatisfied, and the use of "obligationized" is becoming common even in single-income families. These are the same people who, a generation ago, were happy to use whatever words were available; now they utilise them.
MaxwellBuchanan, Jul 27 2016
  

       We were once informed tht something was "A case of nobless oblige". We replied that we weren't going to lay out money on a full case of anything we didn't recognise, especially if they had their knobs missing.   

       She seemed quite offended ... she gave us one of those bulldog-chewing-on-a-wasp glares, handed the sword to an equerry, and went out to walk the corgis.
8th of 7, Jul 27 2016
  

       I think you're going to need several lines. The standard. The gracious male looking for a mate, (preferably one who doesn't slowly shamble), the boss is coming, the office troll is coming... this could get complex, like Japanese bowing.
RayfordSteele, Jul 27 2016
  

       You could call it the 'Hodor' line.
RayfordSteele, Jul 27 2016
  
      
[annotate]
  


 

back: main index

business  computer  culture  fashion  food  halfbakery  home  other  product  public  science  sport  vehicle